Yellow Star: Jennifer Roy
July 31, 2006
Yellow Star
Yellow Star is told from the perspective of Syvia Perlmutter, who was, with her family, locked into the Lodz ghetto when she was 4 1/2 years old. As described in the foreword to the book, 270,000 people were forced into this ghetto during the course of the war. More than five years later, Syvia walked out of the ghetto alive. She was one of only 800 people left. Only twelve of the survivors were children. That's right. Twelve.
More than fifty years later, Syvia (now called Sylvia) told her story to her niece, Jennifer Roy, who found that the best way to tell the story was to tell it in Syvia's own voice. The story is classified as fiction, because of course no one can be sure of every detail, but the book rings true throughout. Because this is Syvia's story, and we know from the introduction that Syvia survives to adulthood, this story isn't as scary as it might be otherwise. I think that's a good thing, because it's quite scary enough. I kept shaking my head throughout the book, reminding myself that this was real, not some movie version of a story.
The book is told in very short sentences, like a young child's memories. This format (it's a free verse novel) makes it easily accessible to kids. There is plenty of white space in the text, and the poems/sections are quite short.
What stands the most in this book, to me, is the strength of love that Syvia's parents had for her. They did whatever it took to protect her and keep her safe under impossible circumstances. Her father, especially, showed himself to be a brave leader, who also helped others outside of the family. As for Syvia, she mostly accepts what's happening to her as inevitable, and tells us about facts. But sometimes she wonders about the bigger picture. For example:
"I am certainly no one special or important.
Just one plain brown-haired, skinny girl.
But I am alive and still here.
Am I lucky?
Surely not as lucky as children
who are not Jews.
But every day I get to be with
my parents and sister,
and in the ghetto that is
more than luck.
It is a miracle."
Syvia goes through terrible things. She loses friends and relatives, and her precious doll. She has to hide from the Nazis, who are removing all of the children. Her family doesn't have enough food, or heat. The Nazis shoot people on the street, and send people off in freight cars. At one point, she resorts to naming and playing with dust bunnies, and calling them her toys. But Syvia maintains her spirit, and the love for her family. She survives, in part through her own actions, and in part through the combined efforts of the adults around her. And that's inspirational.
I highly, highly recommend this book. Yellow Star recounts an important chapter in World War II, from the perspective of an actual child who survived. Hearing about the Lodz ghetto from Syvia, who only gradually comes to understand what's going on herself, should keep the story from being overwhelming for most kids. The strong parental love displayed in the book should also act as a counterweight to balance the more negative elements. This is a book that I'll want to read again, and want kids I care about to read, too.
Book: Yellow Star
Author: Jennifer Roy
Publisher: Marshall Cavendish Children's Books
Original Publication Date: 2006
Pages: 227
Age Range: 10 and up
© 2009 by Jennifer Robinson of Jen Robinson's Book Page. All rights reserved.
quartet by Thomas E. Sniegoski
(and sequels) by Walter Farley
) by Anthony Horowitz
by Rick Yancey.
by Laura Ingalls Wilder
by Orson Scott Card
by James Daugherty
) by David A. Adler
, 
, etc.) by Justin Richards.
from the series by Eoin Colfer.
, etc.) by Inez Haynes Irwin.
by T.H. White
) by Garth Nix
by Michael Ende.
by Chris Abouzeid
by Cornelia Funke
by Gertrude Chandler Warner
by Wilson Rawls
by C.W. Anderson
) by D. J. MacHale.
and 
by Mary Rodgers)
by Angie Sage
by Susan Cooper
, 
, etc. by Gary Paulsen
by Christopher Paul Curtis.
(and sequels) by Madeleine L'Engle.
and sequels by Zizou Corder.
) by Jenny Nimmo
by Roald Dahl.
) by Betsy Duffey
and 
by George MacDonald
by Roald Dahl
by Jim Kjelgaard
e by Louis Sachar
by Scott Westerfeld
by Lloyd Alexander
by Frances Hodgson Burnett
) by Ron Roy
and 
by Jeanne Duprau
by Ian Serraillier
and 
) by C. S. Lewis
by Stephenie Meyer.
by Erich Kaestner
by Donald J. Sobol.
from the Inheritance Trilogy by Christopher Paolini.
by Tony Abbott
series by Megan Whalen Turner
by Sue Corbett.
by Walter Macken.
by Ridley Pearson.
by Eoin Colfer.
by Lilli Thal
by Franklin W. Dixon.
by Johann Wyss
trilogy by J. R. R. Tolkien
by L. M. Montgomery
books by Suzanne Collins.
by Mary Mapes Dodge
by Crockett Johnson.
by Salman Rushdie
by J. K. Rowling.
by Rudyard Kipling
from the series by Beverly Cleary.
by Stephen Crane
) by Cynthia Rylant
, 
by Robert McCloskey
and sequels by Mike Thaler and Jared Lee (illustrator)
by Mark Twain.
(and sequels) by Hilary McKay's.
by Mary Pope Osborne
quartet by Christopher Golden
) by Jack Gantos.
and others by Mordecai Richler
by Charles Higson.
by Roald Dahl
by E. L. Konigsburg.
by Cynthia Lord
by Jeanne Birdsall
by Jerry Spinelli.
by Meindert DeJong
by Sid Fleischman
by Katherine Paterson.
by Robert Louis Stevenson.
by Eric Knight
and others by Jack Gantos
and the sequels
(Children of the Lamp series) by P. B. Kerr.
by Esther Forbes.
by Alexander Key
by Stephen Cole.
by Lois Lowry.
by Alice Dalgliesh
by Elizabeth Burton De Tevio
by Elizabeth Enright
and 
by Mary O'Hara
) by Diane Duane.
books by Lemony Snicket
by Janet Tashjian
by Louisa May Alcott
(and sequels) by John Bellairs
) by Emily Rodda
by Margaret Peterson Haddix
by George Selden
by Alden R. Carter
by Elizabeth George Speare
and 
by Kenneth Oppel.
) by Paula Danziger
by Maurice Sendak.
) by Jane Yolen
by Norton Juster. (Not so much at the beginninng of the book, but he improves.)
by Rudyard Kipling
series by Marjorie Sharmat
by Jean Lee Latham
) by Jonathan Stroud.
by Jonn Bennett
by Andrew Clements.
by F. Scott Fitzgerald
by Jim LaMarche
by E. L. Konigsberg
by Susan Taylor Brown
by Charles Dickens
by Alan Silberberg
and sequels by Elizabeth Enright.
by Lynne Reid Banks
) by Catherine Jinks
by Maureen Johnson
books by Ludwig Bemelmans
and 
by Rick Riordan.
by J. M. Barrie (also cool as portrayed by Dave Barry and Ridley Pearson in 
).
by C. S. Lewis
by Carlo Collodi.
by Charles Dickens
by S. E. Hinton
as portrayed in the Sisters Grimm series (starting with 
) by Michael Buckley
and sequels by Beverly Cleary.
) by Ralph Moody
by Will Hobbs
by Katherine Patterson
by Marguerite de Angeli
by Roger Lancelyn Green or 
by Howard Pyle
series by Emily Rodda
by Markus Zusak
by E.B. White
by Cornelia Funke.
by Holly Black and Tony DiTerlizzi
by Leon Garfield
) by Maj Lindman
by Louis Sachar.
by E. B. White.
) by Lloyd Alexander
by Meindert DeJong
by Thomas Hughes
by Mark Twain
) from the series by John D. Fitzgerald.
by Mark Twain.
by Alexander Key.
by Fred Gipson
by Gary D. Schmidt.
by Gordon Korman
by John Christopher.
by Philip Pullman.
and 
by Elizabeth Winthrop
) by Dan Greenburg and Jack E. Davis
and 
by Scott Westerfeld
by Eva Ibbotson
, by A. A. Milne.
, by Chris Lynch, is told from the perspective of Keir Sarafian, a high school senior, football kicker, and self-proclaimed "good guy". The very first scene depicts Keir in a bedroom having an intense confrontation with Gigi Boudakian, the girl that he claims to love. Gigi rails against him for what he's just done to her. "I said no" she insists. Keir argues with her, and with himself, because the picture in front of him simply can't be right. He is baffled. He can't possibly have just done this to someone he loves.