A Perfectly Messed-Up Story: Patrick McDonnell
March 31, 2015
Book: A Perfectly Messed-Up Story
Author: Patrick McDonnell
Pages: 40
Age Range: 3-6
There is peanut butter plopping onto the page, followed by fingerprints, and orange juice, and then ... deliberate disrespect ... coloring. Louie throws a tantrum because, after all, "books are important". He makes an attempt to withdraw himself from the story altogether. But in the end, he realizes that, well, the book has actually turned out fine.
The illustrations in A Perfectly Messed-Up Story feature a big-eyed character that looks like the little monsters in McDonnell's The Monsters' Monster. He has a toddler-like appearance, even wearing a one-piece romper. His posture and exaggerated facial expressions clearly indicate his displeasure when things go wrong. But the real beauty of the illustrations is the way McDonnell makes it look like there is actually a blob of jelly stuck the page. The various things that defile the book stand out clearly from the rather muted backgrounds, with strong visual cues for young readers about exactly what is going on.
A Perfectly Messed-Up Story is a fun book for preschoolers, though the one-joke storyline may not hold the attention of older kids. There's a subtle lesson about learning to roll with the punches, but the action in the book is so contrary to expectations that kids will be laughing too hard to realize that they have absorbed any message. Recommended for younger readers, and for fans of McDonnell's distinct illustration style. A Perfectly Messed-Up Story would make a fun group read-aloud for library or preschool, too.
Publisher: Little Brown Books for Young Readers (@LBKids)
Publication Date: October 7, 2014
Source of Book: Review copy from the publisher, received for consideration for the Cybils awards.
© 2015 by Jennifer Robinson of Jen Robinson's Book Page. All rights reserved. You can also follow me @JensBookPage or at my Growing Bookworms page on Facebook. This site is an Amazon and iBooks affiliate, and purchases made through affiliate links (including linked book covers) may result in my receiving a small commission (at no additional cost to you).
2015 Waterstone’s Book Prize Winners via 
Tuesday on the 
More 2015 New Releases in LGBTQ Young Adult Fiction, 
Family 
My daughter will be thrilled! Disney Jr to Adapt Fancy Nancy as Animated Movie, TV Series 
We should always play in the classroom by 
Naked! by Michael Ian Black and Debbie Ridpath Ohi is, as you might expect, a celebration of the joys (for preschoolers, anyway) of running around naked. A little boy escapes his weary mother after his bath and runs joyfully all around the house. He enjoys being naked so much that he imagines going to school or the playground naked. He eventually adds a cape to his (lack of) ensemble, and this seems for a time to be the perfect compromise. However, by bedtime, the cold drives him into giving some clothing a try (though the cape stays on, too). And warm and cozy, he falls asleep, slung over mom's shoulder. 
Newsletter Update: In this issue I have six children's book reviews (picture book through young adult), one installment of my new #KidLitFaves series, and two posts with literacy and reading links that I shared on Twitter recently. I also have a review a of book for parents by Nancy Newman on Raising Passionate Readers. 
I'm listening to 
What are you and your family reading these days? Thanks for reading the newsletter, and for growing bookworms. 
For some reason, I thought that 
Kevan Atteberry's Bunnies!!! is an exuberant title that would make a fun read aloud for toddlers and early preschoolers. A not-very-threatening-looking purple monster is walking through the woods, saying hello to anything he encounters, animate or not, when he runs across a group of four colorful bunnies. His enthusiastic cry of "Bunnies!!!" shocks the little rabbits, and causes them to run away. The monster is sad and confused. The same scenario repeats, leaving the monster even sadder. But eventually, as even the youngest readers will expect, the bunnies come around, and a new friendship is made. 
A Tuesday Ten: Remarkable Female Protagonists (inc. Matilda!) in 
Nice 
On the 
Expand Your Horizons: Read Books from Foreign Lands, suggests 
Middle Grade 
How JK Rowling kept her Harry Potter secrets from the world 
Carrying the Torch: Family Members Keeping a Character Alive (Madeline, Babar, + more) — 
Amy 
Top 10 Ways To Get Students Talking about their Reading by 
Who Wants a Hug? by Jeff Mack is a new picture book about a lovable bear and a not-so-lovable skunk. On our first read, I found it cute, but my four-year-old loved it. She had a big smile on her face throughout, and declared it a new favorite. Personally, I found that I appreciated it more on subsequent reads. Bear and Skunk grew on me.
Susan Murray at 
Abby Johnson (aka Abby the Librarian) LOVES children's nonfiction. She 
Tiffa at The Picture Book Review 
I am eagerly awaiting the new Penderwicks books by Jeanne Birdsall, 
For a recent STEM Friday, Robert Gibson at Wrapped in Foil shared "a fabulous new book from Chicago Review Press", 
Katie Fitzgerald from Story Time Secrets 
Charlotte Taylor from Charlotte's Library and I share a fondness for some of the same books from our childhoods. So when she 
Tanita Davis from Finding Wonderland is 
Karen Yingling from Ms. Yingling Reads isn't much of a personal fan of bleak books. However, she's also a librarian who understands that girls go through a particular developmental phase in which they want to read depressing titles. Hence she was "SO pleased" 
Big Game by Dan Smith is a novel based on the screenplay for a 2014 Finnish action-adventure movie. It has an action movie pace, a book that one rushes through to find out what will happen next. I couldn't put it down, and read it in about a day. The narrator is Oskari, a Finnish boy about to turn 13. Oskari is sent out alone into the wilderness near his home on an overnight hunt by his tribe, expected to come home with the head of an animal (the bigger the better). In the woods, Oskari encounters the U.S. President, whose plane has been shot down. Hunted themselves, Oskari and the President must fight for their lives. 
A particularly quirky Tuesday Ten from 
Books That Make Us Cry (Part Two) Collected by 
Our Favorite LGBT-Positive Children's Books 
Reading with Little Miss Muffet: February 2015 
Mr. Schu Finds “Forever Books” for Kids "the kind of book that will live with you forever" 
Serving Conservative Teens: "our job is to help young people find the right book... without judgement"